Paleo Living and Orthodox Lent

Paleo Living and Orthodox Lent

During my first Orthodox Lent, my cradle Orthodox friend Joe Bush remarked (over hummus): “Lent’s funny, you know. When I was growing up, my aunts all gained weight during Lent.”

And he’s unfortunately right—for many of us, we make up for the meat, eggs, and dairy with a heavy load of grains, soy products, and unhealthy faux-meats, while our waistlines suffer the consequences.

But it doesn’t have to be this way. We can follow the Orthodox fasting protocol and still nourish our bodies.

For those who know me, it’s no secret that I adopted a “Paleo” or “Primal” eating strategy last year, shed forty pounds in five months, and lowered my blood pressure—all while traveling across several states, through dozens of cities, and one U.S. territory. These results have elicited many questions and comments from both friends and family, and as Great Lent draws near, I’m being asked how to reconcile the two paths of fasting for spiritual benefit and following a Paleo diet for the sake of good health. (And before I really get going, let me be clear: I am not trying to convert you to “be Paleo,” nor am I trying to stand in the place of your priest or doctor. We must remember our fasting is an ascetical discipline closely connected to our fellowship with each other and God in the Eucharist. Paleo is a health strategy.)

Let’s review the don’ts, and I’ll paint with a fairly broad brush.

Orthodox fast days generally exclude olive oil, wine, and animal products like dairy, eggs, and meat (shellfish is allowed, along with bony fish on other days). Some people opt to wait until 3 pm to eat their primary meal on each fast day, but that’s not the typical approach. Orthodox fasting is on a spectrum—some will take wine to mean all alcohol, or olive oil to mean all oils, and a few will eat fish throughout the fast. And some days on the calendar are simply more relaxed than others.

Paleo is also on a spectrum. Generally, it excludes legumes (beans, peanuts, peas, soy, etc.), grains (corn, wheat, bread, sometimes rice, etc.), processed oils (soybean, canola, etc.), most sugars, most or all dairy, and tends to go easy on high-sugar fruits, starchy vegetables, and tubers (like potatoes). Exceptions abound, and athletic Paleo folks may emphasize resistant starches more than others, and some folks leave off nightshades. Positively, the Paleo diet emphasizes eating on the lower carbohydrate end of things (at least compared to most modern diets), with lots of healthy fats—usually from animal sources, plants (like avocados or nuts), and healthy oils (like coconut or olive oil—choose your olive oil carefully). Organ meats and shellfish are encouraged, and a wide variety of fruits and vegetables round out the plan. The basic idea is lots of plants and animals, closely aligned to their whole and natural state.

So how does one navigate both Lenten guidelines and the Paleo lifestyle?

1. Focus on healthy fruits, vegetables, nuts, and allowed oils as the platform of your diet.

Vegetables, lower-sugar fruits, and perhaps potatoes are the core nourishment during this period, providing you with an essential nutritious foundation. The ANDI Guide (Aggregate Nutrient Density Index) is an imperfect, but helpful resource to help you find the most nutrient-dense vegetables, herbs, and fruits. Kale, basil, cilantro, cranberries, strawberries, carrots, and spinach are all great choices. Try adding fermented foods to your diet, too, such as a few forkfuls of sauerkraut or kimchi with a meal or two a day.

I like to eat a lot of leafy green salads, and I always feel my best when I have one big salad every day (and it can easily be thrown together in just two minutes). Unfortunately, most commercial salad dressings are chock full of yucky stuff. Try vinegar with avocado oil, make your own, or look for brands like Walden Farms, Bragg’s, or Tessemae’s, all of which have oil-free salad dressings, or olive oil dressings and avoid the harmful industrial oils.

Make baba ganoush with avocado oil instead of olive oil; make hummus with mac nuts instead of chick peas; or take the time to soak the chick peas before whipping up a batch, or try to find an oil-free hummus; you can even let cauliflower stand in for rice (or just go ahead and use white rice).

The Paleo approach often emphasizes fat over both protein and carbohydrate. Stock up on coconut or avocado oils, buy fresh avocados regularly, and pick up some nuts. These are good, rich, and healthy fats—crucial fuel to keep you going through the day. Healthy fats will satiate hunger, give you fuel, and help stabilize your energy. That said, don’t go nuts with nuts, avoid peanuts altogether, and beware of nuts roasted in seed oils. And consider trying coconut oil in your coffee for a satiating morning boost.

If you feel like you must have noodles, look into shirataki noodles for a low-carb and gluten-free alternative to wheat or rice-based noodles. You won’t get much nutrition out of shirataki, but it’s a traditional Japanese food, pretty harmless, and is great for, ahem, “encouraging” digestion. Consider something like Miracle Noodle as a source, or a similar, non-soy-based shirataki noodle (there are several soy-based impostors on the market). Miracle Noodle even makes a no-carb “rice” that is plenty edible.

2. Focus on getting your protein from shellfish and plants.

The biggest concern vegans, vegetarians, and Orthodox fasters hear is whether or not one can get enough protein on a plant-based diet. The typical go-to plant-based proteins are beans and other legumes, but it is ideal to soak and/or sprout them first to reduce or neutralize some of the anti-nutrients present. Few do this regularly, and so for most, it’s a no-go, but for some, it’s okay. Tempeh is one possibility; while it is soy, the fermentation process for tempeh makes it an okay choice (but other options are available).

Almonds, broccoli, and spinach are three great sources of plant-based protein. Take the time to browse the Internet for protein content in non-legume vegetables so you can make an informed decision at the market.

Even better, go for shellfish, as the Orthodox fasting guidelines permit crustaceans and shellfish throughout Great Lent. Oysters, clams, shrimp, mussels, scallops, and other shellfish are all wonderful sources of protein.  One of the principles of Paleo living is “eating the animal from nose to tail.” My friend David McGee put it this way:

Those shellfish are roughly equivalent to organ meats of larger animals in their nutrients, and you are eating the whole animal, both plusses. Lots of Paleo diets will emphasize grass-fed meat, but don’t go into detail, so people go for the steak and skip the liver/organs, missing out on the most nutrient dense parts. Oysters, mussels, etc., are very nutrient dense, have the right kind of healthy fats, and may end up being better than the meat you would have picked in a fast-free period. Also, you can eat some of the shellfish raw or minimally prepared, which will preserve the nutrients that cooking can destroy in other meats you may be less inclined to eat raw.

Mussels, for example, are tasty, cheap, ethical, and contain plenty heart-healthy omega-3s. I can get them for $3.99 a pound at my local grocer, for example, and you can play around with cooking them in delicious vegan sauces.

If you’re still concerned about protein beyond these suggestions, you may consider looking for a plant-based/vegan, gluten-free, low-glycemic protein supplement to imbibe once or twice a day.  Either that, or turn to worms and insects.

But seriously:

3. You’re not going to die if you miss out on protein for a few weeks.

Our bodies are extremely adaptable. You can go without protein for a while. You will feel different, but you can do it. We come from people who went days or weeks on end without eating animals. They didn’t starve—they just ate more plants. Intermittent fasting is part of our genetic make-up. The Orthodox fasting rules are Paleo gold, really. Embrace your ancestral roots and eat a little less.

As the Whole30 folks put it:

It is not hard. Don’t you dare tell us this is hard. Beating cancer is hard. Birthing a baby is hard. Losing a parent is hard.

Going without as much protein? This “hard” demon is driven away only by prayer and fasting.

4. Finally, focus on the benefits of intermittent fasting.

As noted above, an important concept in the Paleo community is the concept of intermittent fasting. If we are going to emulate our ancestors, this involves both food choices and food absences. We all descend from people who went days or weeks without eating, or at least without eating animals. Intermittent fasting is part of our genetic make-up, and it is part of the Orthodox tradition. (IF may be a little more challenging for women.)

Many in the Paleo community have adopted strategies like randomizing meal times, fasting for a number of hours, or a compressed eating window, to mimic this aspect of our genetic heritage. And considering we partially fast 180–200 days a year in our Orthodox tradition, well, I’d say that the Orthodox fasting rules are right in line with the goals of this sort of thinking.

We don’t always have to eat, and our tradition teaches us to leave off meals sometimes, and pretty regularly. I say, let’s do it.

Final Thoughts

You may have noticed that this Paleo lifestyle appears to completely omit wheat-based bread. Of course we’re Orthodox, so should not omit the Bread of Life. If you’re following these principles, there is absolutely no dietary reason to forego regular communion, and for most a little blessed bread on top of it is just fine. Proceed with humility and repentance, and don’t get uptight at coffee hour, or at anyone’s house. As they say, “Keep your eyes on your own plate.” Don’t miss any great experiences, and don’t ruffle anyone’s feathers.

The canons, principles, and rubrics of the Church as they currently exist are entirely compatible with a nutritious, dairy-free, and mostly grain-free lifestyle.

Relax. Don’t worry. Eat Lenten and stay Paleo.

– – –

There are a number of helpful resources available for eating vegan/vegetarian and for optimal nutrition. I can’t endorse all content in the links above or below, but all of them are helpful for one reason or another.

Orthodox Resources

Vegan or Vegetarian Paleo Resources

Other Related Material

Just for Fun

Suggested Foods

Sometimes it’s more helpful to put the emphasis on what foods are available, rather than what is forbidden. I remember a Lent a few years ago where I caved and ate a lot of fried chicken because I spent all my time pondering fried chicken as “forbidden fruit.” Here is a handy list of fast-friendly foods, full of nutritional benefits.

13 comments:

  1. Great advice, Jamey. My chiropractor would love this, and so would my daughter who has to eat dairy and gluten-free because of food sensitivities.

  2. Thank you. This is exactly the article I wantted to find and read before entering Great Lent.

  3. Isn’t the whole basis of the paleo diet that humans were evolved over millions of years to optimally extract nutrients from game and wild vegetation and we have not adapted to the phenomena of agriculture and consuming milk after maturation? Isn’t this completely at odds with Orthodox theology that humans were created by God with only superficial changes occurring due to genetic adaptations since? I’m not entirely sure how insistent the church is on young earth creationism but I remember our church had a founded date in both AD and since creation (~6000 years if I remember correctly) carved into its side. And I remember a great insistence that evolution and orthodox theology were irreconcilable.

    1. It’s not an acceptance of evolution. The name (Paleo) bothers me, actually, because I don’t believe in evolution. But I do know that grains affect me badly, and I recently learned that dairy does, too. So Paleo it is. Not as an acceptance of the idea that people evolved through the caveman phase, but as a way for my eating to make my body not hate me. 🙂

      1. That’s a great point, Caroline. It’s one of those “call it what you want” sort of things, and we all have varying levels of toleration of certain foods. I personally like the “ancestral health” moniker, as I think it’s more in line with what I’m personally aiming for, and avoids the loaded philosophy and anthropology of the “paleolithic” moniker. But whether someone is following GAPS, the Specific Carbohydrate Diet, Atkins, 4-Hour Body, Weston A. Price, or “paleo,” the necessity of nourishing foods and the avoidance of potentially inflammatory foods are paramount.

      2. I was so glad to see this blog! You’re right about the greens – I make a very dense green smoothie adding sprouted or soaked nuts and seeds and avacado. But I have also began adding a serving of hemp protein which gives me 20 grams. Amazing what a complete meal it is!

        Linda

        Linda

    2. Hi Justin, thanks for reading. The Paleo community is fairly dominated by an evolutionary paradigm, but there is no reason to suppose that we cannot benefit from the dietary approach. Even if you don’t buy the philosophy, the medical science is worth looking at.

      To my knowledge, Orthodoxy has no particular bias for or against evolution, though certain individuals may lean one way or another.

      Either way, I didn’t write this to convert anyone to paleo eating, but to help folks choose sources of optimal nutrition during the fast. All the best!

  4. I would like to add that olives and some seeds would make a nice addition to a healthy Lenten diet, and if you’re active, sweet potatoes are a great choice, too.

  5. This article is helpful. It reminds us that there can be more to a lenten diet than peanut butter and hummus.

    Sometimes, however, the point of the fast can be missed in our zeal for bodily health. Rather than think more about food, ideally, it should free us up to think less about food, and more about prayer and our souls. We neglect the body a little in order to discover our souls. This involves not just abstaining from certain foods, but even going without food.

    It seems extreme now, but the ancient practice during weekdays of Great Lent for the pious was one meal a day after vespers.

    Many people still do this at least the first week of Great Lent. And believe me, you will lose weight.

    Paleo, Atkins, South Beach, Weight Watchers, Nutrisystems, Body for life… these are the things the world runs after. They can be helpful tools for us, but they can also become a big distraction. The mind loves distractions.

    “Food for the stomach and the stomach for food, but God will destroy them both.” (I Cor. 6:13).

    Let’s eat well, but let’s also not eat well and above all, let’s pray, repent, give alms and seek the Face of God.

Comments are closed.