Worshipping with Muslims

timthumbIn the current cultural debate over Islam, we sometimes meet people who rush to defend Islam and assert that Muslims and Christians both worship the same God. Sometimes they give liturgical expression to this assertion, and participate in joint Muslim-Christian worship services, in which both the Qur’an and the Bible are read. What are we to think of this? Can Muslims and Christians unite in worship? Is it true that they both worship the same God?

The question is deceptively complex, and since Islam post-dates the New Testament by six centuries, the New Testament cannot be expected to provide a direct answer. But the New Testament does help answer a similar question: Do pagans and Christians worship the same God? There were differences obviously, since paganism worshipped many gods and Christianity was staunchly monotheistic. But paganism did in some way dimly acknowledge that there was a supreme god of sorts, called Zeus or Jupiter (depending upon one’s geography). Could Zeus and the God of the Christians be more or less identified?

The answer (frustratingly for those who like to scream about such things on Facebook) is: Yes and No. That is, Yes, since there is only one God, and anyone consciously directing his prayers to The One God will find that The One God of the Christians receives his prayers, since He is the only God that there is. That is what St. Paul meant when he wrote that God is not the God of the Jews only, but also of the Gentiles also “since God is one” (Romans 3:29-30). A pagan might direct his prayers to “the Unknown God”, but these prayers would be received by the God of the Jews and Christians, since He was the only true God who existed (Acts 17:23).   Our God therefore has some sort of relationship to any who sincerely seek Him, regardless of their religion.

But the answer to this question is also No, since all pagan religions had an element of the demonic. Though a devout, ignorant, and well-intentioned Athenian pagan’s prayers to Zeus may have been received by the God of Israel, this is did not mean that his Athenian paganism was more or less interchangeable with Judaism or Christianity. While his heart and intention may have been acceptable to God, his actual religion, cultus, and sacrifice were not.   Paul affirmed that “What the pagans sacrifice they sacrifice to demons and not to God” (1 Corinthians 10:20). Idolatrous worship, though perhaps intended for and aimed at the Most High God, was intercepted and used by the demons, and Christians in the early centuries always regarded pagan religion as infected with the demonic. That is why pagans converting to Christianity in baptism renounced their former religion as the worship of Satan. Pagans and Christians did not in fact find their acts of devotion received by the same God.

This analogy with paganism therefore would suggest that Islamic worship does not, in fact, connect the Muslim worshipper with the one true God of the Christians. Our God is the God who eternally begets the co-eternal Son, and from whom the Spirit eternally proceeds to rest in the Son, and who therefore may be described as the holy, consubstantial, life-creating, and undivided Trinity. The Second Person of that Trinity died by being crucified on a cross under Pontius Pilate—all of which is emphatically denied by the Qur’an. Despite their shared theoretical monotheism, Christian and Muslim worship does not focus upon the same God, and (more importantly) the objective and spiritual reality present through their worship is not identical. In Christian assemblies, Jesus Christ is present, for He has promised to be present whenever two or three gather together in His Name (Matthew 18:20). In Muslim assemblies, Christ is not present in the same salvific way. Rather, just as the early Christians said that the demonic was present in the sacrifices of the pagans, that same terrible reality is present now liturgically in Muslim assemblies.

Does this mean therefore that every Muslim is therefore damned? Like I said, the question is deceptively complex. If a Muslim has no real exposure to or understanding of the Christian message, he might still be spared on the Last Day after all if his heart was in ignorance seeking the true God.  C.S. Lewis wrote about such a possibility in The Last Battle, the last volume of his Narnian series:  a worshipper of the god “Tash” (a thinly-veiled version of Allah) finds himself in the presence of the true God, the lion Aslan, an image of Christ.  He realizes that his life-long worship of Tash was the worship of a false god, and that Aslan was the true God after all.  In his own words, “Then I fell at his feet and thought, Surely this is the hour of death, for the Lion will know that I have served Tash all my days and not him. Nevertheless, it is better to see the Lion and die than to be Tisroc [or, King] of the world and live and not to have seen Him.  But the Glorious One bent down his golden head and said, Son, thou art welcome. But I said, Alas, Lord, I am no son of thine, but the servant of Tash.  He answered, Child, all the service thou hast done to Tash, I account as service to me… But I said also, Yet I have been seeking Tash all my days.  Beloved, said the Glorious One, unless thy desire had been for me thou wouldst not have sought so long and so truly.  For all find what they truly seek.”   I believe this. I believe that those Muslims who have sought the true God so long and so truly may yet be accepted by The One God. I believe that our God, who loves the sinner, will not reject any who are happy to see Him, but will save them through the Cross of Christ.

Do Muslims and Christians worship the same God? No, and therefore Christians should properly avoid a worship service containing elements which suggest that they do. Our task as Christians is to proclaim the Gospel and bring all truth-seeking hearts to the saving and transfiguring waters of baptism. All pagan religions contained some elements of truth, but Paul still proclaimed the one true God to the pagans standing before the altar to the Unknown God on Mars Hill, and exhorted them to renounce their past errors and embrace Christ. We must do the same for the Muslims of our time as well. Our ultimate goal and divine mandate is not co-existence with Muslims but their conversion—as it is for all the children of men.

 

 

 

9 comments:

  1. “If a Muslim has no real exposure to or understanding of the Christian message, he might still be spared on the Last Day after all if his heart was in ignorance seeking the true God.” It is a very strange idea Fr.Lawrance. If a person, according to the fathers of the church, doesn’t find true God here on earth and unite with him through the baptism inside the True Church One Holy Catholic and Apostolic, there is no way for him to be spared on the Last Day. If person doesn’t find True God and His true Church here on earth, there, after death, it will be too late. If a person accepts the idea that some people had no opportunity to understand Christian message, then heaccepts the idea that God is not Almighty, that he somehow can’t bring His Word to those who truly seek Him. But that’s a blasphemy. In Acts we can see a lot of examples of helping those who seek, the most clear is Acts 8:27-39. Or we can see how God does not let the Apostels to preach in Acts 16:6 “Now when they had gone throughout Phrygia and the region of Galatia, and were forbidden of the Holy Ghost to preach the word in Asia, After they were come to Mysia, they assayed to go into Bithynia: but the Spirit suffered them not.” Why didn’t He let them because there was no use as Gregory the Great explained it : “According to mysterious judgement holy preaching is not let to the hearing of some, because these are not worthy of being restored by Grace” (40 Homilies on the Gospel. 4.1). God decides who will be exposed to His message and who will not, because, unlike us, He sees the hearts and know perfectly who truly seeks Him and who doesn’t, and he doesn’t leave and abandon those or hide His message from those who truly seek Him as it is clearly stated in Psalm 9 : “They that know Thy name will put their trust in Thee: for Thou, LORD, hast not forsaken them that seek Thee. ” He who remains till his death in “ignorance” here will have no chance to change his situation there. The Last Day will be the Last day for him. It was also very clearly stated by St. Ignatius Brianchaninov in his letter 203: “Firm teaching of the True Church, both of the New Testament and of the Old Testament. The Church has always acknowledged that there is only one means of salvation: The Redeemer! It has acknowledge that the greatest deeds of the fallen nature go th hell, if the righteous of the True Church … who shined wiht the Holy Spirit, prophets and wonderworkers, who belived in the coming Redeemer, but who died before the Redeemer went to hell, how do you want then mahometans, only because they seem to you good people, when they did not experience and believe in the Redeemer, how do you want them to receive salvation which can be received by only one, one, I repeat to you, way, by faith in the redeemer … He who acknowledges the possibility of salvation without faith in Christ denies Christ and perhaps, without knowing it falls into a terrible sin of blasphemy. ” It is stated very clearly, no salvation without faith, and faith here on earth and not then on the Last Day. Aslan is not Christ, but just a fruit of imagination of some popular British writer and philosopher, that’s why Aslan teaches wrong thing ad christians should not listen to him but to the Gospel and the Saints of their Churh, which is only “the pillar of Truth”.

    1. Thank you for your comments. Dealing at length with the topic of whether or not Christ will spare those who died outside the Church would take us too far afield from the topic of Islam. But I will say that my view on the matter comes not so much from CS Lewis’ words in The Last Battle as from St. Paul’s words in Romans 2:6f, where he says that God “will render to every man according to his works: to those who by patience in well-doing seek for glory and honour and immortality, He will give eternal life, but for those who are factious and disobey the truth and obey wickedness there will be wrath and fury”.

      1. Glory to IC XC!
        An awkward typo, “…seek for glory and honour and *immorality* He will give eternal life…” What a difference a T can make! 🙂
        in XC,
        FBW

        1. Yikes! Thank you for catching it; my heretical spell-checker saw nothing wrong with it theologically and let it through. I must be getting old. It reminds me of one time in church when a reader was reading from the epistle which bid us “shun immorality”, and he ended up bidding us “shun immortality”. Anyway, bless you for the correction!

          1. (Laughing) This “shun immortality” reading error occurred once in my parish also, as well as many other equally humorous reading errors .

            My personal favorite was when our priest forgot to say, “the sins of” and said instead, “Wash away, O Lord, all those commemorated here in Thy precious blood.”

          2. I think every priest must have a collection of them. One priest told me of a time when a reader wanted to to chant about “offering young bullocks on Your altar” (from Psalm 51), and read “buttocks” instead of “bullocks”. Fortunately there were not many in church that time to enjoy the mistake.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.