Recently I read an interesting critique of American Christianity. It pointed out that in an earlier day the schoolrooms for our children used to feature the Ten Commandments written on the wall, rather than (for example) the Beatitudes. The author thought this rather odd for a Christian nation, and evidence that something was wrong. I grant you that the preference for the Ten Commandments over the Beatitudes does invite comment.
One begins by asking how the Ten Commandments became so prominent in the eyes of Christians to begin with. One of course understands how a Jew would opt for the Ten Commandments which Moses brought down from the height of Sinai, rather than the Beatitudes of Jesus found in the New Testament. But how did the Ten Commandments become so culturally popular among American Christians?
In Reformation Protestantism the Ten Commandments were very prominent, and children were required to memorize them as part of their basic catechism, along with the Lord’s Prayer and the Creed.
In the reformed Church of England, the Ten Commandments were recited after the Gospel from 1547, and they were embedded at the beginning of the Communion Service from 1552. Through the work of the Protestant Reformers of the sixteenth century, Moses experienced a thorough liturgical baptism, in that his Ten Commandments took a central place in the lives of Christians.
I remember vividly my time in the Anglican Church when the congregation knelt down at the beginning of the Communion Service as the priest recited each line of the Ten Commandments. The people responded to each Commandment by saying, “Lord have mercy upon us, and incline our hearts to keep this law”. At the end of the recitation of the Commandments, they prayed, “Lord have mercy upon us, and write all these thy laws in our hearts, we beseech thee”. It was all very moving, and (had I but known it then) something specific to Reformation liturgy. The medieval catholic liturgies which Cranmer and his Anglican liturgical architects used as their sources had nothing like this in them. Devotion to the Ten Commandments by Christians seems to have entered American schoolrooms through the door of America’s Protestant inheritance.
One does see, of course, why the Ten Commandments rather than the Beatitudes would be chosen for display in classrooms for young students. Even apart from the ecumenical value of something common to both Christian and Jewish children (but was anyone very ecumenical back then?), the Ten Commandments functioned as a kind of ethical primer, giving the first basic lessons of morality. It would hardly do to give the more advanced moral geometry of the Beatitudes to those still learning their moral multiplication tables. There was no sense trying to inculcate mature spirituality to those just starting out. Why tell youngsters that the poor in spirit would inherit the kingdom of heaven when they needed to be taught not to bully weaker classmates or steal their lunch money? The basics had to come first: do not do this, do not do that. Don’t lie, don’t steal, don’t kill people. These were not budding theologians, but rambunctious kids. They were barbarians needing taming, not seminarians striving for holiness. Bring on the Ten Commandments, and the teacher blowing the whistle at recess.
But that said, the Ten Commandments still have value for adult Christians—as does the entire life of Moses. We might be tempted to dismiss Moses and the Ten Words he received from God on the summit of Sinai as irrelevant to the Christian life. It is true that if one compares Moses to the Lord Jesus, Moses comes off very poorly—but then everyone comes off poorly when compared to Christ. The Old Covenant finds its fulfillment in the New, and such is the light of Christ’s glory in the New Covenant that “what had glory [i.e. the Old Covenant] in this case has no glory on the account of the glory that surpasses it” (2 Corinthians 3:10). But that does not mean that we can now throw the Old Testament Scriptures into the dumpster, as Marcion once suggested. We still read the Old Testament texts to find the wisdom that God put there.
That was why when St. Gregory of Nyssa was asked by his friend Caesarius to instruct him regarding a life of moral perfection, Gregory did not lecture him with abstract concepts, but held up the life of Moses as an example, writing his Life of Moses to offer great Hebrew Lawgiver as an example for all Christians. Moses gave us more than the Ten Commandments (literally the “ten words”; in Hebrew dabarim; in the LXX logous). His entire life was one of devotion to God in the midst of trial, temptation, hardship, and setback. As St. Gregory recognized, we can learn much from the entire life of Moses, not just from the two small tablets in his hands that he brought down from Sinai.
That is why I have written a book on the life of Moses. It is arranged into forty chapters, so that it can be read devotionally throughout the forty days of fasting, either during the Nativity Fast or the Fast of Great Lent. (It can also of course be read through in a single setting, like any other book.) Each chapter deals with an episode in Moses’ life, giving a basic exegesis of the story, and is followed by the moral lessons we can learn from that episode. I hope that St. Gregory would be pleased with it, and that you will be pleased as well. The book is called Walking With Moses, and it is available from St. Tikhon’s Press for $15.26. It can be ordered here.
I have a different suspicion – that the reason for the 10 commandments prominence – has all to do with the grace/works supposed dichotomy in Protestant soteriology. For example, the Westminster Confession:
Q: What is sin
A: Sin is any lack of conformity to, or transgression of, the Law of God.
And Baptists had already modified the Westminster Confession by excluding anything on infant baptism – and made it their own in the London Baptist Confession of 1689.
Luther taught people to preach the Gospel to themselves – but this included going through the Commandments to see where we were failures – and then applying forgiveness, imputation, etc. – to the problem.
John Wesley was converted after reading Luther’s preface to Romans.
Long story short, the Law, being our tutor to lead us to Christ – was wrongfully ascribe to the 10 Commandments alone – and not rightfully to the whole of the Law. So, all law language in Paul usually boils down to 10 Commandment keeping – which is what he supposedly accuses the Jews of in their self-righteousness – when all a long Paul is after the Jew/Gentile distinction being abolished not by doing away with the Commandments – or with turning them into only “proofs of depravity” and need for grace. The Law becomes “what you try and do to work/merit your way to God” and grace becomes “you can’t do it so here’s why you need Christ” – to fulfill the Law/10 C on your behalf, and then impute that to you, and your sins are imputed to Him (not to mention PSA, Election, etc.).
But the whole thing follows Original Sin. The works/Grace dichotomy is broken by Ancestral Sin.
So, my suspicion is, besides a guide to morality, there is a heightened appreciation for the 10 Commandments in Protestantism because – they read Paul wrong for 500 years. They believe the Law/10 C sets up the Gospel – and from here they even read Law into Eden: The Covenant of Works. Everything is either works/Commandment keeping or Grace.
But they just as well could have put the beatitudes up because – these work like the Commandments as well – proving our depravity. These imperatives from Christ are basically impossible because we are so evil (Total Depravity) so, we need Christ as our representative (as Adam is ours – again OS/OGuilt) to work out a righteousness on our behalf we never could. This becomes the Gospel.
This is why there is no compatibility between Orthodoxy and really anyone else – individuals maybe – but institutions, I can’t see it. The incompatibility is about what the Gospel is, and their gospel is set up by Original Sin and Guilt. They have no “gospel” without it.
So, the Commandments would be drilled into a person for two reasons, to see their need for Christ, and also for how to live – or to at least try, knowing you’ll fail miserably over and over – and then the process repeats over and over all throughout your life as you re-preach this gospel to yourself.
In any case repentance is the cure.
Today, I was blessed beyond measure to witness an old man pray a very short, but moving prayer. I happen to be in a place where the old man had quietly been performing “acts of mercy” for about six (6) hours. Yes, he was up BEFORE “first light”. After he attended to the humans in need, he moved on to THEIR animals in need (THEIR “kids”). As he was finishing up, I saw him look UP to Heaven with a pleading look on his face, he said, “Lord, Jesus, the greatest honor I could ever receive is for YOU to let ME pour out myself to OTHERS like You poured out yourself for us.”
That old man must have some of the commandments and the beatitudes written in his heart.
He blessed those humans, he blessed their animals, and he blessed ME!