I never will forget the moment in college when I was confronted with the question “how do you know?” It was in an undergraduate philosophy class and I had actually never really thought about “how” I knew things. The fancy name for this is “epistemology.” And epistemology is the study of how we know. It turns out this is an extremely important question to ponder.
So, how do YOU know what you know? Do you “know” through study or rationalistic trial and error? Do you “know” through experience and observation? Do you “know” because you “feel” that something is so? Or is it a combination of all this? Frankly, we live in an age that really doesn’t contemplate this foundational reality. We live in an age where we assume that what we think we know is true and we all too often fail to examine why we think what we know is true. And that, my dearest, is a dangerous place to be because we make life choices and set our priorities and live our lives based on what we think we know.
Look at our lesson today in Luke 20:1-8:
At that time, as Jesus was teaching the people in the temple and preaching the gospel, the chief priests and the scribes with the elders came up and said to Him, “Tell us by what authority you do these things, or who it is that gave you this authority.” He answered them, “I also will ask you a question; now tell me, was the baptism of John from heaven or from men?” And they discussed it with one another, saying, “If we say, ‘From heaven,’ he will say, ‘Why did you not believe him?’ But if we say, ‘From men,’ all the people will stone us; for they are convinced that John was a prophet.” So they answered that they did not know whence it was. And Jesus said to them, “Neither will I tell you by what authority I do these things.”
As usual, Jesus is being confronted by religious leaders who think they know how all this God stuff works. They are convinced, and their conviction that they know isn’t based on some feeling or even their own egos. They are basing their confidence on the assumption that they are following the traditions of those who came before them. They aren’t trying out something new. They aren’t trying to set some novel precedent. They are convinced they are in the right in confronting this itinerate rabbi from Nazareth. And they are wrong!
But why? Why does what Jesus does and teaches reveal the flaw in their thinking and their whole worldview? Because they don’t go back far enough in examining why they know what they think they know. They fail to see beyond their immediate knowledge. They think that the problem with Jesus is that he doesn’t have the authority to do what He’s doing. And the reason that is so wrong is that they don’t know WHO He really is. He IS the Lawgiver, and the Lawgiver knows the Law and the “why” behind the Law better than anyone else. They think he’s just another loudmouth preacher, and they are not going to allow someone whom they “outrank” in their minds to acts against the status quo! Their ignorance of the Lord’s true identity makes their choices too small, petty, and wrong.
So, the Lord pinpoints for them the spot where they went wrong. They were focusing on the authority of the Lord to do and say the things He was doing and saying. Jesus met them at this wrong spot and asked them to tell Him about John the Baptist authority to do what he did. Immediately these religious leaders started calculating the question, not based on facts or deep theological truths or even on why John was baptizing in the first place. They saw the whole question as a political trap Jesus was setting for them so they said they didn’t know the answer to Jesus’ question. The Lord responded the same. They were right about one thing: they didn’t know why John was baptizing because they had become strangers to repentance and that distance from a lifestyle of repentance made them unable to know how they knew.
Today, are you a stranger to a lifestyle of repentance? That means the hard work of staying attentive to your motives, your “epistemology”, and your actions that flow from the WAY you think. Allow your life to be formed by the wisdom of the timeless faith and the way you “know” will be based on being Orthodox on Purpose!
P.S. Dear Lord, grant me the attentiveness today to know You as my Source for true knowledge and my true Source of authority. Give me the courage to embrace a lifestyle of repentance so that why I do what I do is shaped by WHo I know You to truly be. And grant me, O Lord, the grace to see myself and others as You see me. Amen.